One Foot Tsunami: Notification Summary Miscues

Published on:

Perhaps I ought to just turn these off.

Since they were first enabled last year, I have frequently found Apple Intelligence’s notification summaries for emails to be something less than helpful. Here are some I spotted in just the past few days.

A Pricey Used Book

The notification summary:


That’s one expensive book.

The actual email:

An order for 4 dollars and 27 cents.
Humans readily understand this style of dollars and cents pricing. Robots, it seems, do not.

Excessive Addition (And Alarmingly Incorrect Math)

The notification summary:

A summary showing three numbers added to get a fourth number.
I took two (wicked fun) ebike rides, not three…

The actual email:

A receipt email with two numbers, added to make a third number
…oh, I see what happened here.

Hang on, though. As friend-of-the-site Alex S. pointed out to me, even the math is wrong. $1.28 + $1.17 + $2.45 = $4.90. Setting aside the incorrect extra addition, how did the initial summary get to $5.89? Whence came that extra 99¢?

Incorrect Capitalization

The notification summary:

A summary indicated I have a new balance with New Balance, capitalized like the shoe company.
Did I buy running shoes from my doctor?

The actual email:

An email showing a new balance owed for a medical bill.
No, I did not.

If we set aside the inaccurate addition in the second example, each one of these mistakes is understandable, but still completely stupid. If a human made these errors, you’d correct them, and expect them to get it right in the future. When it’s AI slop, however, it’s hard to envision how the system actually improves.

Source link

Related